| Feature | Rating | Comments |
| Graphics | 10 | Compared to their NES/Famicom forms, the transformation of the 8-bit games into 16-bit is awesome. Some new details were even added not previously seen in the NES/Famicom versions. |
| Sound | 10 | Just like the graphic-retouches, the sound improvements are great as well. Instead of the toy-organ-like sounds of the old Nintendo, they are now replaced with stereo music. |
| Challenge | 10 | All four of these games including in this game pak contribute to the challenge attribute, especially the Lost Levels! Read more about the challenge in each game in the NES/Famicom versions. |
| Replay Value | 10 | A definite 10 for this game! Why in the world would they remake the old classics for the SNES if none of the games had any replay value? This game provides a nice return to the familiarity of the 8-bit Mario games, added with a bit of 16-bit (no pun intended) flair! |
